Much has been made about Iraq meeting benchmarks that have been set by the bipartisan Iraq Study Group. These benchmarks are considered the measure of success or failure by the Iraqi government, and have great emphasis placed on them by many in America. But let’s forget about the ISG benchmarks for a moment and look at another set of benchmarks that are well known in the field of Psychology—Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs.
In 1943, Abraham Maslow published “A Theory of Human Motivation” in which he theorized that humans have a distinct hierarchy of needs in order to survive and develop. Maslow’s Hierarchy works from the bottom up, in the following order:
-
Self-Actualization
-
Esteem
-
Belonging
-
Safety
-
Physiological
In order for a need to be met, the need below it must first be met.
Now let’s apply Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs to Iraq. Remember, this works from the bottom up.
First on the list are “physiological needs.” What is needed to survive. We’re talking the basics like air, food, water, etc.
Iraq has that covered. People are not dying of mass starvation in Iraq like they are in places in Africa. And they certainly aren’t dying by breathing the air like some of them did under the rule of Saddam Hussein. Iraq meets Maslow’s first benchmark.
Next on Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs is “safety.” People not only need to be safe, they need to feel safe. The Surge has been working on both. Violence continues to drop to its lowest levels of the war. People are moving back to their homes. Iraqi’s are beginning to have hope. While this benchmark has not been fully met, many Iraqi’s may feel otherwise, and have gone on to the next.
Maslow’s third need is a sense of “belonging.” This is brought about by friends and family, but in the case of Iraq, that would be better equated to allies and nationalism. Iraqis have an ally in the United States, as long as we don’t desert them while they are vulnerable. And the nationalism will come as new laws continue to be passed that allow all of Iraq’s people and ideologies to be properly represented. Though progress continues to be made, this benchmark has not been completely met, which makes it impossible to move to the next.
Maslow’s fourth need is “self-esteem.” Once Iraq has a sense of belonging, it can work on its self-esteem and confidence. This is when Iraq can stand proudly as a nation amung nations, and begin to make positive marks on the world. This is the place we (should) all want Iraq to be. Where Iraqis are proud to be Iraqis, and that pride and confidence can hopefully lead them to the next benchmark.
Maslow’s final need is “self-actualization.” This is when you have reached the pinnacle of your possibilities as a person, or a nation. Few people or nations reach this stage of development for a multitude of reasons. The best anyone can really hope for is an opportunity to do so, and the ability to recognize it when it comes.
Iraq is a democracy. A democracy is ruled by the people, and people have their own needs and benchmarks. It’s not going to be changes from the top down that makes Iraq, its going to be the changes from the bottom up. We’ve helped Iraq reach stage 3, and are working on number 4.
Is this as far as we go? Are we going to continue to help Iraq become the nation we all hope it can be, or do we let it fend for itself? Do we help it upward or do we watch it slide alone down the ladder we’ve worked so hard to climb together?